TIC TIC BOOM! – My Review of MOTHERLESS BROOKLYN (3 ½ Stars)
Motherless Brooklyn is strictly for genre fans or those who don't need much more from their movies than a high-concept quirk. The world itself is surface-level interesting but the main character is the real hook, so getting more of the world without going deeper on the character, or expressly placing him in different predicaments where he can utilize his unheralded abilities, feels like wheel spinning. This is 144 minutes and takes its sweet time, applying more and more layers of intrigue and period settings like Norton is checking a list of Noir Elements to include in his first directing work in 19 years (Keeping the Faith, anyone?). There's an intelligence to the storytelling and power dynamics, but the movie is also a bit too smart for its own good, losing its way in a convoluted mystery where the pieces don't so much add up as they're just given to you after a long enough wait. It's handsomely made and has plenty of enjoyable actors in supporting roles. The movie, which Norton rewrote completely and set in the 1950s, is an acceptable film noir, but without that specific perspective it would get lost. The book was fascinating from being inside this unique headspace and understanding how Lionel's brain operated with obsessions and various pressure valves. Norton is great in the lead and Lionel feels like a companion portrait to Joaquin Phoenix's Joker, another struggling man given to unconformable physical outbursts that make him feel isolated from society. It's an intriguing vulnerability given sympathy, forethought, and it's an intriguing way to make something old new again through a disadvantaged lens.
He's our eyes and ears into a criminal world that views him as a freak. Lionel Essrog (Norton) suffers from Tourette's syndrome and is given to verbal and physical tics he needs to indulge or else his brain feels like it will explode.
Motherless Brooklyn is a decade-plus passion project for star/adapter/director Edward Norton, and it's easy to see why an actor would want to latch onto the lead role.
I remember reading this novel back in college, so it's been a long road for Jonathan Lethem's crime story to find its way to the big screen.
0 kommentar(er)
